Rated 5 out of 5┬áby Shoes19 Very comfortable, well made boots
I waited awhile for these boots. They were back ordered and I forgot about them. I do wish discounts would be applied to items that we are waiting for and sales passing by...that bring said, these are such great boots. Truly perfect with nearly any outfit. Skirts w/tights, dresses maxi skirts and dresses, pants, jeans. They are impressive shoes, obviously well made. The leather is beautiful, a fine sheen. The color is more of a black with a slight wine, very pretty. You can't go wrong with these boots. I feel mine will give me years of wear. They are a staple and a classic addition to anyone's wardrobe.
February 18, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5┬áby PhoebesMom Best boot ever!
I bought a pair about 3 years ago and am still wearing them almost every day. They are amazing; super comfortable, durable and great with jeans. I wish I could buy another pair for when these finally wear out, but there aren't any left in my size. I hope Madewell makes more of them in additional sizes. I'd pay twice as much !
January 15, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5┬áby BKjeansLuv perfectly cool boots
i love these boots. they are just the right amount of stylish cool. i wear them with everything; skirts, skinny jeans, dresses and even my sweats!! i have received a number of compliments on them and although they are bit shinier than i expected, i love the unique color and feel the more i wear them the better they will look. i ordered a half size up for extra comfort but realized after trying them on that they are true to size. however, i will keep them because i can wear them with thicker socks during the cold weather.
January 3, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5┬áby beautyshopnagel BEST
This boot is, by far, the best thing ever. I was nervous about ordering shoes online, but it fit like a glove. Super stylish and uber classic-looking - it literally goes with EVERYTHING! I'd had nothing but compliments on them.
December 19, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5┬áby plh78 stylish shoes but overpriced for the quality
I was really excited to receive these shoes and loved them when they came in the mail. BUT I have my issues. First, the soles are poorly made (considering how expensive these shoes are). After the first day of wearing them, the bottom of my shoes already looked beat up and stones were ingrained in the soles.
Terribly uncomfortable! I've been trying to break in these shoes forever and it's not working. The leather is too stiff and causing terrible blisters.
end point: fashionable/versatile shoes but comes at a price (in more ways than one). Wouldn't recommend unless they go on sale and you get a good deal
January 9, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5┬áby Bess219 I really loved this shoe until.....
...I noticed that the topmost part of the leather started peeling, where the shoe inevitably creases across the toe area.
I haven't worn these shoes much, either -- about once or twice a week to work since I purchased them a month ago. I sit at a desk and I haven't worn them in inclement weather, so I can't say I can blame the peeling on wear-and-tear (unless cordovan leather always peels at creases, in which case I'd rethink buying such a delicate leather in the future), or on the elements.
The style is impecaable, and they fit like a dream out the box (even for my wide feet). But I am super bummed out that they've started peeling so quickly. These are my first pair of cordovan shoes and I'm not sure if it's the quality of the leather of these particular shoes, or cordovan shoes in general, but I'm really hesitant to purchase this type of leather ever again.
January 14, 2014