Rated 5 out of 5┬áby jpeterman Super Cute
This does run small, I am consistently a Medium and ordered the Large which is perfect. The shirt is short, boxier, and has a high neckline, but I love it that way! Lot's of compliments - very happy with the purchase.
November 17, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5┬áby lynnhd Gorgeous, but SIZE UP!
If you like this style - delicate, boho, pretty details - you will love this shirt! It is soft and delicate, has beautiful details, and is exceptionally flattering. For the price (on sale), it cannot be beat. The only issue, which is easily fixed, is that it runs at least a full size small. I am a true small across all brands, and a small or extra small at Madewell. I purchased a medium in both the white and black. To be clear, it wasn't that the shirt was too tight in my regular size, it was that it was too short - the proportion was all off (I'm 5/5, so this is not a typical problem). When I tried on the medium, I found that it fit basically the same - I didn't lose any of the flattering fit in the shoulder/yoke/etc. - but it was longer. This shirt is a little sheer, but not so much that I would need a cami - just enough to be subtly sexy.
October 18, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5┬áby Poca Detail and Fit
Less than 5' tall and <85lbs.
Size XS fits well.
I haven't had the chance to try the size XXS and cannot comment.
But I like the size XS and glad I bought this blouse.
September 11, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5┬áby rightmeow Feminine & Cute
I'm sad to hear that the other reviewers had bad experiences with this top because I love it! I think it's very cute, and I sized up my usual xs to small. It has lots of cute details and it will be perfect for the transition from summer to fall. It's definitely light enough that you can wear it right now during the cooler summer nights.
August 28, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5┬áby dimsum Pretty, pretty weird
Pretty details and soft material, but this top doesn't seem to sit quite right on anyone. A lot of reviews say it's too small, so I thought it would be perfect for me (5'0, 110lbs, ordered an XS). Sleeves are not tight, length is just right. The lace+buttons bib is fitted and the pleated bottom half is very roomy - comfortable, but more balloon-like than boxy. But the weirdest part is the button spacing, which is revealed any time I move my arms: unbuttoned, the upper-half does not lie flat and makes a sloppy side silhouette. Buttoned, the bib pulls apart, flashing odd glimpses of chest.
But... it's pretty.
January 16, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5┬áby jamiemk Super cute but weird fit
Read all the reviews and was warned about the sizing. Usually wear a S at Madewell but went with the M. Really pretty shirt with great detailing. However, it pulled across the chest, am I am really small busted. The bottom had too much material. I couldn't return it because it was on clearance, but gave it to a co-worker. She is about two sizes smaller than me (XS at Madewell) and the M fit her great.
November 14, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5┬áby cabby wanted to love it
I was excited to receive this shirt. I ordered the black shirt and the quality is lacking. It was so thin and wispy that a cami is a must underneath. However, that is not the part that was the most disappointing. The shirt is so short and wide. The sleeves are not 3/4 or long sleeve but somewhere in between. Almost like the shirt was made for petites. Would have returned it but it was a final sale.
December 10, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5┬áby Indigogirl Boring and poorly cut
I was very disappointed when my package arrived. The shirt is boring and very average. The fabric is super thin and the blouse is poorly cut. The proportions are just weird. Don't botherÔÇŽ move to another item.
October 30, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5┬áby scrubbedface too sheer
The blouse was too sheer, you can clearly see your belly-button through it. Also the neckline was a little to high even unbuttoned. It would have been more flattering if it was a little more open/scoop-necked. I like the idea of a black peasant top but will be returning it.
September 8, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5┬áby Snowqueen Disappointing Fit
This shirt is very pretty and well made, but the fit is ridiculously small. I am 5'4" and 126 and my usual size small looked like a child's shirt. It barely fell to my waistband on my jeans and pulled across my 32b chest. I think even a size medium would be too short.
I am rarely disappointed in my Madewell purchases, but this was a miss.
July 25, 2014